Comparing Design Patents and Utility Patents

Comparing Design Patents and Utility Patents

You've finally created a really unique but practical chair - something that would look perfect in the pages of Architectural Digest. You're also savvy enough to realize you should look into protective legal steps before unveiling it to the public (and rival designers). So you'll just apply for a standard patent, right? Well, not exactly. It's a common assumption that there's one general application process to have a patent granted. In fact, there are actually three types of patents (utility, design and plant) each with a distinct path for obtainment.

Not too many people are mistaken about whether their invention qualifies for a plant patent (which protects new varieties of - you guessed it - plants). But it's easier to confuse whether an invention qualifies for a design patent or utility patent, and it's important to decide this issue at the beginning of your search for protection. That's because applying for a patent typically involves considerable investments of time and money.

Under U.S. patent law, a utility patent protects "any new and useful process, machine, article of manufacture, or composition of matter, or any new and useful improvement thereof." A design patent protects a "new, original, and ornamental design for an article of manufacture." In short, utility patents protect the way something is made and used; design patents protect the way something useful looks.

If you've come up with a new type of engine (a machine), engine part (manufactured article) or an improved way of manufacturing engine parts (a method), then you're more likely looking for a utility patent. On the other hand, if your invention lies in the uniquely formed shape of a car's hood and fenders, then (assuming this new shape doesn't also improve the way the car works) you probably need a design patent.

Another example of an invention eligible for a utility patent is a jacket that contains an improved insulation system. A jacket whose invention lies completely in the unique curves of its lapels would better qualify for design patent protection. While the first invention improves the use of the jacket (keeping the user warm), the second invention is a design change that does not alter overall function.

There are a number of other differences between utility and design patents beyond appropriate subject matter and scope of protection. These include possible application types, required application elements, the examination process and length of patent terms.

Inventions typically qualify for only one type of patent. In rare cases, an invention will qualify for both types of protection, or for both design patent and copyright protection (and sometimes even trademark as well). Either way, you should be clear on what type of patent you are applying for because of the important differences between them.
 

 
  • Comparing Design Patents to Copyrights and Trademarks
    Most people understand that it's important to take steps to protect their creative design. The confusing part can be figuring out what type(s) of intellectual property protection are needed. Each type of protection covers certain subject matter and offers specific rights to its owner. Thus, it's...
    read more
  • Comparing Design Patents and Utility Patents
    You've finally created a really unique but practical chair - something that would look perfect in the pages of Architectural Digest. You're also savvy enough to realize you should look into protective legal steps before unveiling it to the public (and rival designers). So you'll just apply for a...
    read more
  • Definition of a Design Patent
    A design patent is a form of intellectual property protection which allows an inventor to protect the original shape or surface ornamentation of a useful manufactured article. This applies to any unique form or otherwise perceivable design features of an object - for instance, a chair, table, hand...
    read more
  • Filing Requirements for Design Patents
    There are several components to a design patent application, though the bulk of the preparation time will typically center on the drawings section. The main elements are:
    read more
  • Design Patent Searches
    http://www.legalzoom.com/patent-search/patent-search-overview.htmlDuring the application examination process, a search of prior patents and published applications ("the prior art") is conducted by the USPTO to determine whether your design is truly novel. There are of course advantages to having a...
    read more
  • Introduction to Design Patents
    For years you've been tinkering with the objects in your house to give them more pizzazz. The kitchen clock has been cleverly reshaped to look like a cup of coffee. You've refitted your lamps with shades funky enough to match the retro theme of a room. Even the pet's food bowls have had a serious...
    read more