What Are the Limitations of Copyright Protections?

As a creator, copyright law protects you from those who would copy and exploit your work for financial gain. However, copyright protection has some limits you should know about.

Find out more about intellectual property basics

Trustpilot star rating bar
Man crafting pottery on a workbench

Contents

Updated on: July 23, 2024
Read time: 4 min

Creators of all stripes have long relied on copyright to protect their creative works from exploitation by infringers, but these protections are not absolute. The limitations of copyright can include the duration, fair use, resale rights, and more.

What are the Limitations of Copyright Protections

With an earlier precedent in English law and enshrined in Article I, Section 8 of the U.S. Constitution ("To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries"), copyright law allows creators a limited monopoly from which to profit from their work, thus providing an incentive for creativity.

Copyright law in the United States protects "original works of authorship" by granting several exclusive rights to the owner of the copyright.

Generally, copyright protection under American law protects the copyright holder for the duration of the life of the author plus 70 years. For works made for hire where the employer owns the copyright, the copyright duration is generally either 95 years from the date of its first publication or 120 years from its creation, whichever expires first.

'Fixing' the creative work

An idea not sufficiently "fixed"—made into a tangible medium—is not eligible for copyright protection. Also, your creative work must have sufficient heft for copyright protection to apply. Short phrases or snippets of creative work might not qualify for copyright protection (although, in the right circumstances, they may be eligible for trademark protection).

Registration and the right to damages

While it is true that copyright protection takes hold whenever a creative work is fixed in tangible form, registering a copyright with the U.S. Copyright Office can provide the copyright owner with the ability to collect damages and attorney's fees in federal court.

While the protections afforded under copyright law are powerful, there are some limitations to that protection, including the following.

First sale doctrine

An exception to the distribution rights of copyright owners, the "First Sale" doctrine states that copyright owners lose distribution rights to any specific medium containing the copyrighted work once that medium was first sold. Thus, authors do not collect royalties on, for example, used books.

Digital millennium copyright act

Say you are the author of a registered copyright and you discover your work being reproduced in an online forum. As the copyright owner, you may have recourse against the individual member of the forum, but against the forum itself? Not so fast. The Digital Millennium Copyright Act of 1998, or DMCA, provides for a "Notice and Takedown" procedure where the copyright owner provides notice to the online service provider of an infringement, allowing the provider some time to investigate and take down the infringing work.

So long as the online service provider follows the DMCA procedure, that forum is shielded from copyright liability even though that forum did publish a copyrighted work. Also, the functioning of the internet depends on cached files; that is, files that are copied and stored on the computer or the network. Although such copying would technically be a violation of copyright law, the Digital Millennium Copyright Act protects such use.

Fair use

Perhaps the most prominent defense in any copyright action is fair use, which can be seen as a "transformative" use of the copyright holder's work for the public interest. What it is that constitutes "transformative" versus something intended to exploit your rightful copyright rights is something courts have grappled with for centuries. A court would weigh, in a very fact-specific manner, the amount of the copyrighted work used, the purpose of the use, whether the usage damages marketability of the copyrighted work, and the standards of the industry in question. There are several avenues on which a fair use defense can be asserted, including:

  • Commentary. You may have created a work garnering praise or criticism. Such commentary on your work might require using a portion of your work, and, so long as that portion is limited to commentary and not intended as a means to exploit your work, such commentary could be considered fair use.
  • Parody, but not necessarily satire. These concepts are often confused, but the difference can be important for copyright purposes. Parody is a kind of commentary on the copyrighted work, while satire often uses the copyrighted work to make a social comment not directly related to the copyrighted work. Courts often find parody to be a fair use of copyrighted work, but not as often for satire.

Copyright protection is a powerful deterrent from unlawful exploitation of your created work. Understanding its limitations will help you determine when and if to pursue action against those who use your copyrighted work for their own purposes.

Find out more about intellectual property basicsStart Now
Twitter logoFacebook logoLinkedIn logoReddit logo

This article is for informational purposes. This content is not legal advice, it is the expression of the author and has not been evaluated by LegalZoom for accuracy or changes in the law.

33 days ago
Trustpilot star rating bar

Confident First-Time Filing

The process was clearly explained, and all of my questions were answered. I feel confident about the next steps, which I appreciated as first-time trademark filer.

David
89 days ago
Trustpilot star rating bar

I was so impressed with Juan's…

I was so impressed with Juan's step-by-step guidance! It made the trademark process so digestible and easy. He answered any question that came up and made something I was dreading go by quickly and easily.

Amelia Samuels
115 days ago
Trustpilot star rating bar

Jose is the best.

Jose was very friendly and knowledgeable. He was able to answer my questions and provide me information of next steps to secure my trademark.

Cheryl Cooper
118 days ago
Trustpilot star rating bar

The knowledge the agent possessed was…

The knowledge the agent possessed was super beneficial to rectify the situation I was having with my trademark. Very professional!

Craig Schsrfman
134 days ago
Trustpilot star rating bar

Trademark work is great and effecient

Edit from my previous feedback and why i decided to give them 5stars they deserved: LegalZoom's support team was excellent—they addressed my concerns promptly and delivered a great outcome. I truly appreciate their help and want to give a shout-out for an outstanding customer service experience.

Trademark
133 days ago
Trustpilot star rating bar

Thanks for being so helpful in the…

Thanks for being so helpful in the assist of getting my Trademark filed. -Patrick

Patrick Thompson
140 days ago
Trustpilot star rating bar

Kevin was able to help me understand…

Kevin was able to help me understand the process needed for filing a trademark. He was clear in his answers and stayed on the phone to help walk through the onboarding.

Asiyah Lites-Rasheed
158 days ago
Trustpilot star rating bar

Excellent Serviceed them for a trademark application

Used them for a trademark application. Excellent service. Knowledgeable staff. I would absolutely use them again. Probably save thousands by going through them.

Eric Hertz
189 days ago
Trustpilot star rating bar

Help with trademark

Got exactly what I needed to register my trademark

Luci Bromberg
45 days ago
Trustpilot star rating bar

Legal Zoom Rocks

Michelle Rodriguez is not only a Star in your team but a kind, generous thoughtful and efficient person. I know Michelle will solve my problem and handle my new Copyright request with excellence. Once again Legal Zoom Rocks!

Nicholas Ash
68 days ago
Trustpilot star rating bar

Tamika is warm, smart, and effective.

Tamika is warm, knowledgeable, and effective. She answered all of my questions about taking the necessary steps to get a copyright on a song that I wrote and performed. I hope to work with Tamika in the future on this musical project. Sincerely, Rosemarie Mattke

Rosemarie Mattke
90 days ago
Trustpilot star rating bar

Obtaining a Copyright

I had some questions about copyright, and he answered all of them. He was pleasant to talk to very professional. I was very pleased. I've been using legalzoom for many years, and I love you guys. Thank you.

NORINA PURRO
91 days ago
Trustpilot star rating bar

Happy customer

Ms. Green, was very helpful in assisting me step-by-step in guiding through the process in getting my copyright application. She was patient and very polite. She offered to follow-up on my completed, make sure the process was successful.

Ayesha
97 days ago
Trustpilot star rating bar

Superior Customer Service

Superior customer service and expertise from Patti Green. I have a urgent need for an attorney consultation regarding state level copyright law. Ms. Green quickly and seamlessly steered me to the plan which affords this service. The consult was immediately scheduled for the next day. To say the least, this experience was exemplary.

Guy Hampson
102 days ago
Trustpilot star rating bar

Copyright registration

Karen helped me immensely during my copyright registration. Very patient. Carrie was alos very good over there.

rjparadee
146 days ago
Trustpilot star rating bar

So far whenever I have tried to work…

So far whenever I have tried to work with Legal Zoom it has been a great experience. Both Holly and Denise have helped to make my tour of the legal process for a copyright excellent and I now have my copyright in my hands. I might add that I am amazed I got it under the oligarchy at all after doge got done.

Connie Lednum
140 days ago
Trustpilot star rating bar

Great Copyright Registration Experience

Walked me through the process to register my copyright. Made everything quick and easy!

Cheryl C
159 days ago
Trustpilot star rating bar

Your expertise and knowledge of my…

Your expertise and knowledge of my questions regarding my copyright I applied for was nothing less than stellar!

Lorenzo Vito
22 days ago
Trustpilot star rating bar

Thank you Maria for walking me through…

Thank you Maria for walking me through the patent filing process requirement and step by step walkthrough.

Sabaji Naik
168 days ago
Trustpilot star rating bar

Short wait time to get through to a…

Short wait time to get through to a representative who listened and answered my questions calmly and thoroughly, so I could make an educated choice on the patent package options.

G.L. Van
175 days ago
Trustpilot star rating bar

This is my 2nd provisional patent with…

This is my 2nd provisional patent with Legal ZOOM. This time I dealt with Mak Champ he was Great, went out of his way to make it as easy as possible. Thank You

JoeSnook
201 days ago
Trustpilot star rating bar

Great Experience with LegalZoom

My experience in submitting a Provisional Patent Application has gone very smoothly so far. Customer Service and Support was very prompt and answered all my questions very quickly. I highly recommend Legal Zoom.

Viki Mann
259 days ago
Trustpilot star rating bar

Sandra helped me make the additional…

Sandra helped me make the additional orders on my account for the patent information. She helped me on everything I asked for. Thank you for making a difficult process much easier. thnx.

Rodney Kreinbrink
320 days ago
Trustpilot star rating bar

Tiffany was patient,professional and thoughtfully thorough!

Tiffany was patient, professional and thoughtfully thorough in her assisting me through procedures involving my patent processing!!

Valued Customer DT
320 days ago
Trustpilot star rating bar

Professional and Kind

Carrie was extremely helpful in answering my general questions regarding the trademark and provisional patent application process and fees. She was clear and succinct while maintaining a level of kindness and understanding of my needs. She provided the exact information I needed, saving me time and effort in researching via other routes. Thank you!

Teresa
Rated4.6out of 5 based on24,942+ reviewson

Showing our favorite reviews